Despite concerns about the Delta variant and breakthrough coronavirus cases, it’s clear that the vaccines are protecting us from hospitalization and death. Typically, breakthrough infections result in mild to moderate symptoms or no symptoms at all.
That’s good news. But it doesn’t answer one big question: What’s the risk of so-called long Covid after a breakthrough infection?
While most people recover from mild to moderate Covid-19 in a few weeks, long Covid is a perplexing set of symptoms — brain fog, fatigue and muscle pain, to name a few — that can persist for weeks or months after the active infection has ended. And it doesn’t happen only to people who had serious illness; sometimes long Covid affects people who had mild illness or no symptoms at all. And while many viruses, like influenza, also can lead to long-term fatigue and other symptoms, long Covid appears to be more common, although more data is needed. Several studies suggest that 10 percent to 30 percent of adults who catch the virus may experience long Covid.
But most of what we know about long Covid comes from people who were infected before vaccines became available.
What we know
Much of what we know about long Covid in fully vaccinated people comes from a single study of antibody levels in Israeli health care workers who had breakthrough infections. Among 36 health workers with breakthrough infections, seven (19 percent) had lingering symptoms after six weeks, including loss of smell, cough, fatigue or trouble breathing.
But even the study’s own authors say the study wasn’t designed to assess the risk of long Covid. “It was not the scope of this paper,” said Dr. Gili Regev-Yochay, the study’s senior author and the director of the infection prevention and control unit at Sheba Medical Center in Israel.
While we can’t draw conclusions about the risk of long Covid from the experiences of seven patients, the finding confirms that long Covid can occur after a breakthrough infection. It isn’t clear, though, how common it might be or when those who have it might recover.
What we don’t know
Several physicians and scientists have told me they are frustrated that we don’t have more data about the risk of breakthrough infections and the course of illness that follows.
“If mild breakthrough infection is turning into long Covid, we don’t have a grasp of that number,” Akiko Iwasaki, an immunologist at the Yale School of Medicine, told me.
One of the reasons we know so little is that the C.D.C. collected nationwide data on all breakthrough infections for just four months before ending the practice in May. Now the agency tracks only breakthrough cases that result in hospitalization or death. The C.D.C. director, Dr. Rochelle Walensky, defended the decision last month, noting that the agency was collecting additional data from more than 20 cohorts, including groups of medical workers and people in long-term-care facilities.
“We are absolutely studying and evaluating breakthrough infections in many different sites, many different people across the country,” Dr. Walensky said. “We are looking at those data on a weekly to biweekly basis, and we will be reporting on those soon.”
The bottom line
In some ways, the fact that we know so little about long Covid after breakthrough infection is good news. The fact that doctors haven’t seen large numbers of post-vaccination cases of long Covid suggests that breakthrough infections are still relatively uncommon, and long Covid after vaccination remains a relatively low risk.
We may learn more in the near future, as the Delta variant causes new infections, including, presumably, more breakthrough cases. If some of those breakthrough patients develop symptoms of long Covid, they’ll start showing up in doctor’s offices in the coming months, said Zijian Chen, medical director of post-Covid care at Mount Sinai Health System in New York.
Of course, the best way to avoid long Covid is to avoid getting Covid in the first place: get vaccinated, wear a mask and avoid spending time in enclosed public spaces when you don’t know the vaccination status of others. “The fewer infections we have in the general population, the fewer cases of long Covid we’re going to have,” Chen said.
You can read more in my article today about long Covid after vaccination.
Tara Parker-Pope is the founding editor of Well. You can follow her on Twitter at @taraparkerpope.
More on the virus:
The number of Americans younger than age 50 hospitalized with Covid has hit a pandemic high.
The Texas governor can ban mask mandates — at least for now — after the State Supreme Court on Sunday temporarily stayed a ruling that would have allowed schools to mandate face coverings.
THE LATEST NEWS
The death toll from a major earthquake that struck Haiti on Saturday rose to nearly 1,300. Tropical Depression Grace, expected to dump rain on the island today, may complicate rescue efforts. Florida also braced for Tropical Storm Fred.
The Biden administration has revised the food stamp program’s nutrition standards, permanently increasing per-person monthly benefits by more than 25 percent.
Canada will hold an early election next month. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau hopes it will give his Liberal Party a majority in Parliament.
The Americans most harmed by pollution are also the Americans most harmed by society as a whole, Margaret Renkl writes in The Times.
Staycation: Take a trip to the Isle of Wight.
Quiz time: The average score on our most recent news quiz was 8.5. Can you beat that?
Advice from Wirecutter: Get a bike helmet you’ll want to wear.
Lives Lived: Pat Hitchcock O’Connell was an actress, but her father — the director Alfred Hitchcock — cast her in only three of his films. “I would have loved it if he had believed in nepotism,” she once said. O’Connell died at 93.
ARTS AND IDEAS
A new must-have for TV and movie shoots
Working on sets can be challenging. Some TV and movie companies are hiring therapists to help, Alex Marshall reports.
The jobs vary: Some projects bring in therapists before filming to help writers work with dark material. Other times, therapists are available to the cast and crew once filming begins. When Amazon’s series “The Underground Railroad,” about people escaping slavery, was filming in Georgia, the therapist Kim Whyte was on the set. “Some of the cast and crew were disturbed by the content — just the institution of slavery,” Whyte said. Others wanted to talk about issues at home.
It’s part of an effort to make film productions healthier workplaces. “You’re pushed, pushed, pushed and pushed to the limit, all the time,” Sue Quinn, a location manager, told The Times. The priority is often to make sure projects remain on budget, she said, and crew and actors are often bullied or asked to work exhausting hours.
Joy Gharoro-Akpojotor, a writer and producer, said she first worked with a therapist while writing a short film about her experience of seeking asylum in Britain. She then decided to make the therapist available to members of the cast and crew on several other productions, including an upbeat Christmas movie. “It should be part of how we all work,” Gharoro-Akpojotor said. “We don’t know what anyone’s working through.”